- If the address will be your login on websites for years, take Gmail or Outlook. Neither closes your account as long as you sign in at least once every two years, and both recover access through your own phone and recovery email.
- Firstmail is handy when a program reads the mail, because the login and password work over IMAP right away. The mailbox only lives as long as its domain is paid for, so ask the seller how long that is before you buy.
- In the first hour after buying, add your own recovery email, change the password and turn on 2FA. The seller's guarantee should last at least 7 days, because that is how long Google may keep sending codes to the old contacts.
Your email opens every other account you have. Password reset links and sign-in codes land there, so whoever reads your mail can take over everything registered to it. Pick a mailbox by how firmly you can hold on to it, not by price.
That makes one question matter most when you buy: does the seller still have a back door? You can change the password in a minute, but with their own phone or recovery email the seller can simply reset it again.
Which mailbox fits what you need?
Two things decide it: who reads the mail, you or a program, and how long you need the mailbox. If you open it yourself in a browser, any of the three will do. With a program the difference is big. Gmail and Outlook no longer let mail programs in with just a password, and Firstmail still does.
Gmail
A good fit if the address will be your login for years and you will open it yourself.
- IMAP always on
- programs: OAuth or app password
- may be deleted after 2 idle years
Gmail is accepted almost everywhere, but Google's strict protection gets in a buyer's way. Changing the password, setting up forwarding and turning on 2-Step Verification are sensitive actions, and for them Google wants confirmation from the recovery phone or from a device that has been signed in for at least 7 days. If you have neither, Google may hold the action for a week. The mailbox is not broken. Just try again later from the same device.
Since 14 March 2025 Google no longer lets third-party programs in with a plain password. They need to sign in through Google's own window (that is what OAuth means) or use a 16-digit app password, which only exists when 2-Step Verification is on. An "IMAP enabled" note on a Gmail listing adds nothing: according to Gmail help, IMAP has been on for everyone since 2025.
Outlook and Hotmail
A good fit if you need Xbox, OneDrive or Office, or a second reliable mailbox next to Gmail. @hotmail.com and @live.com addresses work the same way.
- IMAP may be off
- programs: OAuth2 only
- closed after 2 idle years
Since 16 September 2024 Microsoft no longer lets mail programs sign in with a username and password, as heise also reported. That is why Outlook is sometimes sold with a long token string: it is a key that lets a program read the mail without the password. You don't need it for the browser. IMAP itself may be switched off, and you turn it on in the mail settings under "Forwarding and IMAP".
If you strip all the security info off the account at once, meaning the seller's phone and recovery email, Microsoft restricts the account for 30 days. You cannot change the password during that time, and the notifications go to the old contacts, which means to the seller. So add your own contacts first and remove theirs afterwards.
Firstmail
A separate mail service at firstmail.ltd, which is where the search "firstmail ltd" comes from. Its mailboxes often come bundled with a bought account that was registered to them.
- access: webmail and IMAP
- programs: login and password
- lives while the domain is paid
In a browser you open the mail through Firstmail webmail with the address and password. The same page has a password reset that shows which recovery methods the mailbox has. A program connects over IMAP to imap.firstmail.ltd on port 993, and POP3 uses port 995. These addresses are listed in the firstmail library description, and on 26 October 2026 we checked that the server answers on both ports. No tokens are needed, so Firstmail is the easiest of the three to plug into a script.
Its weak spot is lifespan. Mailboxes live on the service's domains, and the Firstmail shop sells "eternal" mailboxes next to ones on domains that last a year. Once a domain stops being renewed, the mail on it disappears, and so does your way to recover any account tied to it. The site has no published rule on deleting mailboxes nobody signs in to. Offers from different sellers are in the Firstmail section, and Gmail and Outlook are in the main email section.
For accounts you would hate to lose, I would use Gmail or Outlook, because their rules are known in advance. I would keep Firstmail for mail that a program reads and for mailboxes that came with an account. In the second case, move the account itself to your main email straight away if the platform allows it. Then the domain's lifespan no longer matters to you.
Five traps in a bought mailbox
Start by reading the delivery format. A login:password line only gets you in. If another address follows after a colon, that is the recovery email, the mailbox where the service sends a password reset link. A long string at the end of an Outlook line is usually a token for programs. Age alone does not protect a mailbox: an old one is lost just as easily if the recovery contacts belong to someone else. Check for these five traps while the guarantee still runs.
- The seller's recovery email or phone
Through that contact the seller can reset the password at any moment, even after you change it. And after you replace the contacts, Google may keep sending codes to the previous address and number for 7 days.
How to tell: in both Google and Microsoft, open "Security" and look at the recovery email and phone. An unfamiliar address hidden behind asterisks almost certainly belongs to the seller. - Someone else is still signed in
The seller may still be in the mailbox on their own phone. Changing a Google password signs you out almost everywhere, but devices that were used to confirm a sign-in stay signed in.
How to tell: in Google, see "Your devices" under "Security". In Microsoft, open the Recent activity page, which shows sign-ins from the last 30 days. - Mail is forwarded to someone else
The password is yours now, but copies of your mail, sign-in codes included, go to the seller. It takes one setting or one filter.
How to tell: in Gmail settings, check the "Forwarding and POP/IMAP" and "Filters" tabs; in Outlook, check Mail, then Forwarding. They should be empty or show your own address. - "IMAP enabled", yet the program can't sign in
For Gmail and Outlook, the password from a login:password line works only in a browser. A program has to sign in with OAuth, and Gmail also offers app passwords, which need 2-Step Verification on your phone.
How to tell: for a program, an Outlook delivery should include a token, and a Gmail mailbox must let you turn on 2-Step Verification with your own number. Firstmail only needs the login and password. - A guarantee shorter than the service's restrictions
The seller gives you a day to check, while Google may refuse a password change for a week. If a problem shows up on day five, the guarantee has already run out.
How to tell: the listing states how long the guarantee lasts and what it covers. For Gmail look for at least 7 days; for Firstmail ask about the domain term.
How not to lose the mailbox after you buy it
Almost everything happens in the first hour. After that, keep two deadlines in mind: a week at Google, and a month at Microsoft if you remove all the old contacts at once.
- Sign in from the device you will keep using
A familiar device makes it easier to prove the mailbox is yours, so don't switch phones or computers during the first week.
- Check devices, forwarding and filters
Sign out of other people's sessions and delete forwarding to unknown addresses. Otherwise sign-in codes will keep reaching the seller even after the password change.
- Add your own recovery email and phone, then remove theirs
For the recovery email, use another mailbox you check every day, as Google also recommends. With Microsoft, remove the old contacts only after adding yours, or the 30-day wait kicks in.
- Change the password
Pick a long password you use nowhere else and keep it in a password manager. At Google, a password change also revokes every app password, so the seller's old programs stop reading your mail. If Google won't let you change it, that is the one-week wait, not a fault.
- Turn on 2FA and save the backup codes
With two-factor sign-in a password alone is not enough; you also need a code from an authenticator app. In case you lose the phone, Google gives you 10 single-use backup codes, and Microsoft gives you a recovery code. Keep them in your password manager.
- For Firstmail, check recovery
Open the Firstmail password reset page and see which recovery methods the mailbox has. If there are none, the password is your only key, and an important account is better moved to your main email.
- Sign in at least once a year
Google and Microsoft close accounts after two years without sign-ins, so one sign-in a year leaves you a margin.
Gmail or Outlook for an account that should last years? If you don't need Microsoft services, take Gmail, because its address is accepted almost everywhere. Take Outlook for Xbox, OneDrive or Office, or as a second mailbox that serves as the recovery email for the first.
One caveat concerns programs. If your own script reads the mail, check before buying that it can sign in with OAuth, otherwise it won't work with Gmail or Outlook.
Rules and time limits come from the Google and Microsoft help centres, and the Firstmail details from firstmail.ltd. The accsly.io editors checked the Firstmail IMAP and POP3 servers on 26 October 2026.